Before engaging a conversion optimization agency, it is worth spending an hour on your own website with a structured checklist. This does three things: it helps you understand where your biggest conversion opportunities are, it gives you a benchmark to compare against what an agency tells you in their pitch, and it helps you ask better questions during the evaluation process.
Homepage Clarity Check
Read your homepage headline and ask: does it tell a visitor exactly what you do, who you do it for, and what they get? Is the value proposition specific or abstract? Can someone unfamiliar with your business understand it in five seconds?
Also check: is there a single, clear CTA above the fold, or are there multiple competing options? Is the CTA specific ("Book a Free Strategy Call") or generic ("Contact Us")?
Landing Page Relevance Check
For each active paid campaign, check that the destination page matches the specific audience and message of the ad. Does the headline on the landing page reflect the promise of the ad? Is the page focused on a single conversion action, or does it have navigation and links that pull visitors away?
Mobile Performance Check
Open your most important pages on a mobile device - not a desktop preview, an actual phone. Is the text readable without zooming? Are buttons large enough to tap accurately? Do forms work properly with a mobile keyboard? How long does the page take to load on a mobile connection?
Form Friction Check
Count the fields in your lead capture forms. Is each one genuinely necessary to follow up with the lead? Could you remove one or two and still have what you need? Is the form labeled clearly? Is the submit button specific about what happens next?
Page Speed Check
Run your homepage and key landing pages through Google PageSpeed Insights. Note the score and the specific issues it identifies. A score below 50 on mobile indicates significant speed problems that are likely affecting conversion.
Social Proof Check
Is social proof present on your key conversion pages - near the form or CTA, not just on a testimonials page? Is it relevant to the specific audience the page is targeting? Are testimonials attributed to real companies and individuals?
What to Bring to an Agency Evaluation
After completing this checklist, you have a clear picture of your current situation. Take that into any agency evaluation conversation. Ask them what they see as the highest-priority opportunities. A good CRO agency will ask you about your current conversion rates, your traffic sources, and your goals before making recommendations. One that leads with generic recommendations without understanding your specific situation is not doing proper discovery.
If you are still deciding whether outside help is worth it, read why businesses hire website conversion optimization experts.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I check before hiring a CRO agency?
Homepage clarity, landing page relevance to paid traffic, mobile performance, form friction, page speed, and social proof presence. These checks take an hour and tell you both where your biggest opportunities are and how to evaluate what an agency proposes.
What should a CRO agency provide in their initial proposal?
An evidence-based audit of your current conversion performance, specific hypotheses for improvement with supporting rationale, a testing methodology, clear reporting metrics, and a realistic timeline for initial results.
Does LeadStrong provide a conversion audit before engagement?
Yes. LeadStrong's website conversion optimization services start with a structured conversion audit of your key pages before making recommendations. Book a free strategy call to start the process.
Ready to get a professional conversion audit of your website?
Book a free strategy call